Best Value Automatic SUV Under 12 Lakh: Brezza vs Nexon
The demand for automatic transmissions in the compact SUV segment has seen a high growth, with buyers looking for a balance between convenience, features, and value. Let’s compare the Maruti Suzuki Brezza AT and Tata Nexon AMT variants to determine which offers the best value for money.
Variants Overview
Tata Nexon
– Pure S AMT: ₹11.00 Lakh
– Creative AMT: ₹11.80 Lakh
– Creative DT AMT: ₹11.90 Lakh
Maruti Suzuki Brezza
– VXi AT: ₹11.10 Lakh
Key Comparison Parameters
Features vs Price Analysis
| Feature Category | Nexon Creative AMT (₹11.80L) | Brezza VXi AT (₹11.10L) | Nexon Pure S AMT (₹11.00L) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Safety Features | 6 airbags, ESC, 5-star GNCAP | 2 airbags, ESC, 4-star GNCAP | 6 airbags, ESC, 5-star GNCAP |
| Infotainment | 7″ touchscreen, 4 speakers | 7″ touchscreen, 4 speakers | 7″ touchscreen, 4 speakers |
| Convenience | Auto climate, cruise control | Manual AC | Manual AC |
| Special Features | Drive modes, LED lighting | SmartPlay Studio | Drive modes |
Performance Comparison
| Parameter | Nexon AMT | Brezza AT |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | 1.2L Turbo | 1.5L NA |
| Power | 118.27 bhp | 101.64 bhp |
| Torque | 170 Nm | 136.8 Nm |
| Transmission | 6-speed AMT | 6-speed AT |
| Mileage (ARAI) | 17.18 kmpl | 19.8 kmpl |
| Top Speed | 180 kmph | 159 kmph |
Ownership Costs
| Cost Factor | Nexon AMT | Brezza AT |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Tank | 44L | 48L |
| Ground Clearance | 208mm | 198mm |
| Boot Space | 382L | 328L |
| Service Interval | 15,000 km | 10,000 km |
| Global NCAP Rating | 5-star | 4-star |
Key Observations
Value Proposition
Tata Nexon AMT Variants
Strengths:
– Superior safety with 5-star rating
– More powerful turbocharged engine
– Better ground clearance
– Larger boot space
– More airbags across range
Weaknesses:
– Lower fuel efficiency
– Smaller fuel tank
– AMT transmission not as refined
Maruti Suzuki Brezza AT
Strengths:
– Better fuel efficiency
– Larger fuel tank
– Smoother automatic transmission
– Lower price point
– Proven reliability
Weaknesses:
– Basic safety features
– Less powerful engine
– Smaller boot space
– Lower ground clearance
The Verdict: Best Value-for-Money Choice
Overall Value Winner: Tata Nexon Pure S AMT
– Justification:
* Best safety package at lowest price point
* More powerful engine
* Essential features covered
* Better ground clearance and boot space
Best Feature-Rich Option: Tata Nexon Creative AMT
– Justification:
* All safety features plus premium conveniences
* Full LED lighting
* Auto climate control
* Premium features with 5-star safety
Best Efficiency Choice: Maruti Brezza VXi AT
– Justification:
* Better fuel efficiency
* Smoother transmission
* Larger fuel tank
* More refined driving experience
For the value-conscious buyer, the Tata Nexon Pure S AMT emerges as the best overall package, offering class-leading safety, performance, and essential features at the lowest price point. The Creative AMT variant justifies its premium with additional features while maintaining the core strengths.
The Brezza AT makes sense for buyers prioritizing fuel efficiency and transmission refinement, though it compromises on safety features and performance. Its proven reliability and lower running costs make it a practical choice for high-usage buyers.
Choose the Nexon Pure S AMT if you prioritize:
– Maximum safety
– Better performance
– Value pricing
– Higher ground clearance
Opt for the Brezza AT if you value:
– Fuel efficiency
– Transmission refinement
– Lower running costs
– Brand reliability