Hyundai i20 IVT vs Tata Altroz DCT: Premium Automatic Hatchback Face-off (2024) | Family Car Guide

Key Considerations

Hyundai i20 Sportz IVT:

1. Established Brand: Hyundai's reputation for reliability and quality (with a reported 95% customer satisfaction rate).

2. Smooth Transmission: IVT (Intelligent Variable Transmission) offers seamless driving experience.

3. Fuel Efficiency: Impressive ARAI-rated mileage of 20 kmpl.

4. Spacious Interior: Class-leading wheelbase of 2580mm offers ample space for family comfort.

5. Modern Features: 8-inch touchscreen with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay.

6. Safety: Equipped with 6 airbags for comprehensive protection.

Tata Altroz XMA Plus S DCT:

1. Indian-Focused Design: Developed with a focus on Indian road conditions.

2. Advanced Transmission: 6-speed DCT (Dual-Clutch Transmission) for responsive performance.

3. Safety: 5-star Global NCAP safety rating, showcasing excellent build quality.

4. Spacious Boot: 345 liters of cargo capacity for family needs.

5. Unique Design: Distinctive exterior with wide-opening doors for easy access.

6. Value Proposition: Competitive pricing in the segment.

Let's look at what the numbers throw up:

1. Price:

- Hyundai i20 Sportz IVT: Rs 942,799

- Tata Altroz XMA Plus S DCT: Rs 909,900

- Price difference: Rs 32,899 (Altroz is 3.5% cheaper)

2. Engine Performance:

- i20: 86.76bhp, 114.7Nm

- Altroz: 86.79bhp, 115Nm

- Both cars offer nearly identical engine outputs

3. Fuel Efficiency:

- i20: 20 kmpl

- Altroz: 18.5 kmpl

- The i20 is 8.1% more fuel-efficient, which could result in savings over time.

4. Dimensions (in mm):

- Length: i20 3995 vs Altroz 3990

- Width: i20 1775 vs Altroz 1755

- Height: i20 1505 vs Altroz 1523

- Wheelbase: i20 2580 vs Altroz 2501

5. Boot Space:

- i20: 351 liters

- Altroz: 345 liters

- The i20 offers 1.7% more cargo capacity.

6. Safety Features:

- i20: 6 airbags, ABS with EBD, ESC, Hill Hold Assist

- Altroz: 2 airbags, ABS with EBD, Corner Stability Control

7. Infotainment:

- i20: 8-inch touchscreen with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay

- Altroz: 7-inch touchscreen (Android Auto and Apple CarPlay not specified)

Exterior Design:

The Hyundai i20 commands attention with its contemporary aesthetic, blending sophistication with functionality. Its facade is dominated by an intricate parametric jewel pattern grille, a standout feature that immediately catches the eye. Sharp character lines sculpt the i20's profile, creating a sense of motion even at standstill.

In contrast, the Tata Altroz breaks from convention with its unique styling cues, presenting a silhouette that demands notice. Where the i20 whispers elegance, the Altroz boldly proclaims its presence.

Both vehicles showcase distinctive design approaches: the i20 embodies refined modernity, while the Altroz champions adventurous individuality, each appealing to different aesthetic sensibilities in the automotive landscape.

Interior and Comfort:

The i20's interior a showcase in thoughtful design and high-quality materials. It embraces a contemporary aesthetic with clean lines and uncluttered spaces.

In contrast, the Altroz prioritizes practicality and comfort, with its outstanding feature being the wide-opening doors that significantly enhance accessibility.

Both vehicles offer inviting seating arrangements designed for passenger comfort. However, the i20 gains an edge in interior space due to its longer wheelbase, potentially offering additional legroom

While each car presents a distinct interior design approach, both the i20 and Altroz demonstrate a commitment to creating welcoming, user-friendly cabins tailored to meet the diverse needs of modern drivers and their families.

Driving Experience:

The i20's IVT system prioritizes smooth operation, delivering a seamless driving experience. In contrast, the Altroz's DCT (Dual Clutch Transmission) offers potentially quicker responses, catering to a more dynamic driving style.

When navigating urban environments, the i20 excels in providing a composed and refined ride. The Altroz, with its DCT, presents a more interactive driving experience, potentially offering greater driver engagement in city traffic scenarios.

Practicality:

When considering trip variety, the i20 and Altroz each have unique strengths. The i20's slightly more spacious boot offers the flexibility to pack extra items, crucial for family outings.

In contrast, the Altroz's wide-opening doors streamline the process of entering and exiting the vehicle, as well as placing items in the cabin.

Feature Comparison

1. Infotainment: The i20 offers a larger 8-inch touchscreen with confirmed Android Auto and Apple CarPlay support, compared to the Altroz's 7-inch display (connectivity options not specified).

2. Safety: While the i20 boasts 6 airbags, the Altroz counters with its impressive 5-star Global NCAP rating. It's like choosing between a car with more individual life jackets versus one with a sturdier hull.

3. Comfort Features: The i20 offers automatic climate control and rear AC vents, while the Altroz provides manual AC. Think of it as the difference between a smart thermostat and a traditional one.

4. Convenience: The i20 includes features like push-button start and cruise control, which are not mentioned for the Altroz. It's like having a few extra shortcuts on your smartphone.

Recommendation

For those seeking comfort, the Hyundai i20 Sportz IVT will be the car of choice. Despite being slightly more expensive (3.5% higher), it offers a more comprehensive package that aligns well with family needs. Its superior fuel efficiency (8.1% better), longer wheelbase for more interior space, and a richer feature list make it a compelling choice for daily family use. Hyundai's reputation for reliability (95% customer satisfaction) further solidifies its position as a sensible choice for families.

However, if safety is your top priority and you appreciate unique styling, the Tata Altroz XMA Plus S DCT presents a strong alternative. Its 5-star Global NCAP rating and competitive pricing make it an attractive option for safety-conscious buyers on a tighter budget.