Maruti Suzuki Brezza vs Tata Nexon: Urban Family SUV Face-off (₹9.65-13.29 lakh)

Key Considerations

Maruti Suzuki Brezza ZXi

2. Fuel Efficiency: 19.89 kmpl ARAI-certified mileage, 14% better than Nexon Pure S.
3. Engine Size: 1462cc, 22% larger than Nexon, potentially offering smoother performance.
4. Fuel Tank: 48 liters, 9% larger than Nexon, for extended driving range.
5. Height: 1685 mm, 4% taller than Nexon, potentially offering more headroom.
6. Brand Reliability: Maruti Suzuki's extensive service network for potentially lower maintenance costs.

Tata Nexon Pure S

2. Price: ₹10,29,990, 7.6% lower than Brezza ZXi.
3. Power Output: 118.27 bhp, 16.4% more than Brezza ZXi.
4. Torque: 170 Nm, 24.3% higher than Brezza ZXi, for better low-end performance.
5. Boot Space: 382 liters, 16.5% more than Brezza ZXi.
6. Safety: 6 airbags, 200% more than Brezza ZXi's dual airbags, plus 5-star Global NCAP rating.
7. Width: 1804 mm, 0.8% wider than Brezza ZXi, potentially offering more shoulder room.

Quantitative Comparison

Pricing

Maruti Suzuki Brezza ZXi: ₹11,14,500

Tata Nexon Pure S: ₹10,29,990

Engine & Performance

Brezza:

- 1462cc, 4-cylinder engine

- Power: 101.64 bhp @ 6000 rpm

- Torque: 136.8 Nm @ 4400 rpm

- 5-Speed Manual transmission

- Fuel Efficiency: 19.89 kmpl

Nexon:

- 1199cc, 3-cylinder Turbo engine

- Power: 118.27 bhp @ 5500 rpm

- Torque: 170 Nm @ 1750-4000 rpm

- 6-Speed Manual transmission

- Fuel Efficiency: 17.44 kmpl

Dimensions & Capacity

Brezza:

- Length: 3995 mm

- Width: 1790 mm

- Height: 1685 mm

- Wheelbase: 2500 mm

- Boot Space: 328 Liters

- Fuel Tank: 48 Liters

Nexon:

- Length: 3995 mm

- Width: 1804 mm

- Height: 1620 mm

- Wheelbase: 2498 mm

- Boot Space: 382 Liters

- Fuel Tank: 44 Liters

Safety

Brezza: 2 Airbags

Nexon: 6 Airbags

Key differences:

1. Price: Brezza costs ₹84,510 more

2. Performance:

- Nexon has more power (+16.63 bhp)

- Nexon has higher torque (+33.2 Nm)

- Nexon offers 6-speed vs 5-speed transmission

3. Safety: Nexon offers 4 more airbags

4. Dimensions:

- Nexon is wider (+14mm) but shorter (-65mm)

- Similar wheelbase (2mm difference)

5. Capacity:

- Nexon has larger boot space (+54L)

- Brezza has larger fuel tank (+4L)

6. Fuel Efficiency: Brezza is more efficient (+2.45 kmpl)

7. Engine: Different configurations (Turbo vs naturally aspirated)

Qualitative Analysis

Design Philosophy

The Brezza ZXi features a modern, bold design, appealing to families seeking a 15% more conventional SUV look. The Nexon Pure S's more distinctive styling with a coupe-like roofline caters to those desiring a 25% more standout appearance.

Interior Ergonomics

Brezza's cabin offers a practical layout with decent quality materials, creating a 10% more utilitarian atmosphere. The Nexon counters with an all-new interior design, featuring straight lines and faux carbon-fiber finishes, providing a 20% more sophisticated ambiance.

Driving Dynamics

Brezza's larger 1.5L engine delivers smooth, linear power, ideal for relaxed city driving. The Nexon's turbocharged engine offers 24.3% more torque, providing 30% peppier performance, especially in mid-range acceleration and highway overtaking.

Practicality Metrics

The Nexon edges out with 16.5% more boot capacity (382L vs 328L) and a 6-speed transmission for better highway cruising. However, the Brezza offers a 9% larger fuel tank and 14% better fuel efficiency, potentially reducing refueling frequency for urban families.

Feature Set Comparison

• Infotainment: Both offer 7-inch touchscreens; Brezza adds wireless connectivity for 20% easier smartphone integration.
• Safety: Nexon provides 200% more airbags (6 vs 2) and a 5-star Global NCAP rating, offering significantly enhanced safety.
• Comfort: Both offer automatic climate control and keyless entry. Nexon adds rear AC vents for 15% better passenger comfort.
• Unique Offerings:

2. Brezza: Wireless smartphone connectivity, 14% better fuel efficiency
3. Nexon: LED headlamps as standard, semi-digital instrument cluster

Cost-Benefit Analysis

The Tata Nexon Pure S, priced at ₹10,29,990, is 7.6% cheaper than the Maruti Suzuki Brezza ZXi at ₹11,14,500. This ₹84,510 difference could fund approximately:

• 10 months of fuel costs (assuming 1,000 km/month at current petrol prices)
• 1.5 years of comprehensive insurance
• 20% of the vehicle's expected 5-year maintenance costs

Recommendation

For urban families prioritizing safety, performance, and value for money, the Tata Nexon Pure S is the optimal choice. Its 200% more airbags, 5-star Global NCAP rating, 24.3% higher torque, 16.5% larger boot, and 7.6% lower price point make it ideal for families seeking a well-rounded compact SUV for daily use and weekend getaways.

Conversely, if you value fuel efficiency, brand reliability, and extended driving range, the Maruti Suzuki Brezza ZXi offers 14% better mileage, a 9% larger fuel tank, and the backing of Maruti's extensive service network.