Toyota Glanza AMT vs Tata Altroz DCT: Budget Premium Hatchback Guide 2024

Top Reasons for Consideration

Toyota Glanza S AMT:

1. Fuel Efficiency: An impressive ARAI-rated mileage of 22.94 kmpl, translating to significant fuel savings.

2. Brand Reliability: Toyota's reputation for durability and quality provides long-term peace of mind.

3. Spacious Interior: 2520mm wheelbase ensures ample cabin space, a boon for tall passengers.

4. Comfort Features: Automatic climate control and adjustable steering for an enhanced driving experience.

5. Safety: Equipped with ABS, EBD, and dual airbags for comprehensive protection.

6. Infotainment: 7-inch touchscreen system with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay connectivity.

7. Transmission: 5-Speed AMT offers convenience in city traffic without compromising fuel efficiency.

8. Styling: LED taillights and chrome accents contribute to a premium aesthetic.

Tata Altroz XMA Plus DCT:

1. Advanced Transmission: Dual-Clutch Transmission (DCT) for smoother gear shifts and potentially sportier driving experience.

2. Family-Friendly: Automatic transmission at a competitive price point.

3. Cargo Space: 345-liter boot capacity for increased storage (8.5% more than the Glanza).

4. Safety Rating: Impressive 5-star Global NCAP safety rating, a standout feature in this segment.

5. Ride Quality: Well-balanced suspension for comfort in various driving conditions.

Let's see how the numbers stack up:

1. Pricing:

• Glanza S AMT: Rs. 825,000

• Altroz XMA Plus DCT: Rs. 859,900

(Glanza has a 4.1% price advantage)

2. Engine Specifications:

Both feature 1.2L petrol engines

• Glanza: 88.50bhp@6000rpm, 113Nm@4400rpm

• Altroz: 86.79bhp@6000rpm, 115Nm@3250rpm

3. Transmission:

• Glanza: 5-Speed AMT

• Altroz: 6-Speed DCT

4. Fuel Efficiency:

• Glanza: 22.94 kmpl

• Altroz: 18.5 kmpl

(Glanza offers 24% better fuel economy)

5. Dimensions:

• Length: Both 3990mm

• Width: Glanza 1745mm, Altroz 1755mm

• Height: Glanza 1500mm, Altroz 1523mm

• Wheelbase: Glanza 2520mm, Altroz 2501mm

6. Boot Space:

• Glanza: 318 liters

• Altroz: 345 liters

7. Weight:

• Glanza: 935-960 kg

• Altroz: Not specified

8. Ground Clearance:

• Altroz: 165mm

• Glanza: Not specified

9. Safety:

Both offer dual airbags and ABS with EBD

The Glanza leads in fuel efficiency and has a slight power advantage, while the Altroz offers a more advanced transmission and larger boot space.

Exterior Design:

The Toyota Glanza S AMT adopts a conservative yet elegant design philosophy. Its chrome-accented grille, sleek headlamps, and LED taillights contribute to a premium aesthetic. The 15-inch wheels, while smaller than some competitors, provide a balanced profile.

In contrast, the Tata Altroz XMA Plus DCT boasts a more avant-garde approach. The distinctive shark nose-inspired front end, featuring a sleek black grille and sweeping headlights, creates a bold first impression. The dynamic window line and uniquely positioned rear door handles on the C-pillar add to its unconventional charm, though this design choice may polarize opinions.

Interior and Comfort:

Step inside the Glanza, and you're greeted by a well-designed interior prioritizing functionality and comfort. Key features include:

• Automatic climate control

• Fabric upholstery

• 4.2-inch digital cluster

• 60:40 split rear seat for added versatility

The Altroz's cabin, while perhaps not as cutting-edge as its exterior, offers a pleasant environment. Noteworthy elements include:

• Free-standing 7.0-inch touchscreen positioned for easy visibility

• Spacious front seats

• Flat-bottomed steering wheel for a sporty feel

However, the Altroz lacks some comfort features present in the Glanza, such as automatic climate control.

Driving Experience:

The Glanza's 1.2L engine, paired with the 5-speed AMT, is engineered for smooth and efficient performance. The power steering and tilt steering column contribute to easy maneuverability, especially in tight city spaces.

On the other hand, the Altroz's 1.2L Revotron engine with the 6-speed DCT might offer a more engaging driving experience, especially at higher RPMs. The Altroz is known for its well-tuned suspension that effectively absorbs road imperfections, providing stability at higher speeds.

Practicality:

The Altroz offers a larger boot (345 liters vs. 318 liters), providing an 8.5% advantage in cargo capacity. Both vehicles feature similar 37-liter fuel tanks. The Glanza's 60:40 split rear seat adds flexibility for cargo management, a feature not specified for the Altroz in the given data.

Feature Comparison

Infotainment and Connectivity:

• Glanza: Touchscreen with Android Auto & Apple CarPlay, 4 speakers

• Altroz: 7-inch touchscreen with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay

Safety Features:

• Glanza: Dual airbags, ABS with EBD, rear camera, ISOFIX child seat mounts

• Altroz: Dual airbags, ABS with EBD, rear camera

Comfort and Convenience:

• Glanza: Automatic climate control, power windows, keyless entry, push-button start

• Altroz: Electric temperature control, power windows, keyless entry

Exterior Features:

• Glanza: LED taillights, 15-inch wheels

• Altroz: LED taillights, 16-inch alloy wheels

Additional Features:

• Glanza: Toyota i-Connect, Smart Playcast Audio

• Altroz: Specific additional features not detailed in the provided information

The Glanza demonstrates an advantage in terms of comfort and connectivity features. Its automatic climate control and comprehensive infotainment system are likely to resonate with tech-savvy young professionals. However, the Altroz counters with larger wheels and its distinctive exterior design.

Persona-Price Based Recommendation

For a style-conscious, tech-savvy young professional in the Rs. 8-10 lakh price range, the Toyota Glanza S AMT emerges as the recommended choice. Despite its 4.1% lower price point, it offers superior value through a combination of advanced features and excellent fuel efficiency.

Key factors supporting this recommendation:

1. Efficiency: 24% better fuel economy translates to long-term savings.

2. Comfort: Automatic climate control enhances the daily driving experience.

3. Technology: Comprehensive infotainment system with smartphone integration caters to tech-enthusiasts.

4. Brand Reliability: Toyota's reputation for quality provides peace of mind.

5. Space: Longer wheelbase suggests ample interior room.

While the Tata Altroz XMA Plus DCT is a competent alternative with striking design, advanced transmission, and a larger boot, the Glanza's overall package of efficiency, features, and brand value makes it a more compelling option for this specific buyer persona within the given price range.