Toyota Glanza G AMT vs Tata Altroz DCT: Premium Hatchback Comparison (2024) | Family Car Review

Top Reasons for Consideration

Toyota Glanza G AMT:

1. Impressive fuel efficiency: 22.94 kmpl (ARAI certified)

2. Generous interior space: 2520 mm wheelbase

3. Toyota's renowned build quality and reliability

4. Advanced features: Voice commands and Toyota i-Connect

5. Enhanced safety: Six airbags

6. Comfortable ride: MacPherson Strut front suspension

7. Potentially lower maintenance costs

Tata Altroz XMA Plus S DCT:

1. Advanced transmission: 6-speed DCT for responsive performance

2. Distinctive design: Wide-opening doors (90 degrees) for easy access

3. Spacious cargo area: 345 liters boot capacity

4. Top-tier safety: 5-star Global NCAP rating

5. Well-balanced ride and handling characteristics

6. Innovative features: Wearable key and umbrella holder in doors

7. Tata's improving brand image and safety focus

Let's break down the key specifications:

1. Pricing:

- Toyota Glanza G AMT: Rs 928,000

- Tata Altroz XMA Plus S DCT: Rs 909,900

2. Engine Specifications:

- Glanza: 1.2L Petrol, 1197 cc, 88.50bhp@6000rpm, 113Nm@4400rpm

- Altroz: 1.2L Revotron, 1199 cc, 86.79bhp@6000rpm, 115Nm@3250rpm

3. Transmission:

- Glanza: 5-Speed AMT (Automated Manual Transmission)

- Altroz: 6-Speed DCT (Dual-Clutch Transmission)

4. Fuel Efficiency (ARAI):

- Glanza: 22.94 kmpl

- Altroz: 18.5 kmpl

5. Dimensions:

- Glanza: 3990mm (L) x 1745mm (W) x 1500mm (H), Wheelbase: 2520mm

- Altroz: 3990mm (L) x 1755mm (W) x 1523mm (H), Wheelbase: 2501mm

6. Boot Space:

- Glanza: 318 liters

- Altroz: 345 liters

7. Safety Features:

- Glanza: 6 airbags, ABS with EBD, rear camera

- Altroz: 2 airbags, ABS with EBD, 5-star Global NCAP rating

8. Infotainment:

Both feature a 7-inch touchscreen with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay

The Glanza stands out with superior fuel efficiency and more airbags, while the Altroz offers a more advanced transmission and a higher Global NCAP safety rating. The Altroz is slightly larger, potentially offering more interior space, but the Glanza's longer wheelbase could translate to better legroom.

Exterior Design:

The Toyota Glanza sports a an elegant design that remains just conventional enough, featuring a sleek grille and well-proportioned body that appeals to a broad audience.

The Tata Altroz boasts a more avant-garde aesthetic with its distinctive front end and large swept-back headlights. The Altroz's 90-degree wide-opening doors are a standout feature, offering easy access – a boon for families with young children or elderly members.

Interior and Comfort:

Both vehicles offer well-designed interiors with quality materials. The Glanza's longer wheelbase contributes to a spacious feel, complemented by features like automatic climate control and a 4.2-inch digital cluster.

The Altroz offers a layered dashboard design and a flat rear floor, potentially offering better comfort for three rear passengers.

The Glanza's inclusion of a rear center armrest could be a deciding factor for families who frequently embark on long drives.

Driving Experience:

The Glanza's 1.2L engine is known for its refinement and smooth power delivery, paired with a 5-speed AMT for comfortable city driving. The Altroz's 6-speed DCT should theoretically provide smoother and quicker gear changes, potentially offering a more engaging driving experience.

However, the Altroz's three-cylinder engine might not match the refinement of the Glanza's four-cylinder unit.

Ride and Handling:

Both cars offer commendable ride quality. The Glanza's MacPherson Strut front suspension is well-tuned for Indian road conditions, striking a balance between comfort and handling. The Altroz impresses with its driving dynamics, offering a slightly firm but well-balanced ride that handles rough roads confidently and provides good stability at higher speeds.

Practicality:

The Altroz edges ahead with its 345-liter boot space, compared to the Glanza's 318 liters. Both cars offer 60:40 split rear seats for added versatility.

The Altroz's wide-opening doors and flat rear floor enhance its family-friendly practicality

Feature Comparison

Infotainment and Connectivity:

- Both offer 7-inch touchscreens with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay

- Glanza: Toyota i-Connect, Hey Toyota, Smart Playcast Pro

- Altroz: Specific connectivity features not detailed in the provided data

Comfort Features:

- Both: Automatic climate control, keyless entry, push-button start

- Glanza: Rear AC vents, rear center armrest

- Altroz: Cooled glovebox (feature known but not specified in data)

Safety:

- Glanza: 6 airbags, ABS with EBD, rear camera, ISOFIX child seat mounts

- Altroz: 2 airbags, ABS with EBD, 5-star Global NCAP safety rating

Convenience:

- Both: Height-adjustable driver seat, rear defogger

- Glanza: Tilt & telescopic steering, cruise control

- Altroz: Rain-sensing wipers (known feature but not specified in data)

Exterior Features:

Both offer LED headlamps and taillights, and 16-inch alloy wheels

The Glanza offers more airbags and additional comfort features like rear AC vents.

The Altroz commands superior Global NCAP safety rating and some unique convenience features.

Both cars are well-equipped for their price range, with the Glanza potentially offering a slight edge in terms of feature count.

Persona-Price Based Recommendation

For comfort-seeking family buyers in the Rs 8-10 lakh price range, both the Toyota Glanza G AMT and Tata Altroz XMA Plus S DCT present strong cases. However, the Toyota Glanza G AMT emerges as the recommended choice for several reasons:

1. Superior fuel efficiency (22.94 kmpl vs 18.5 kmpl), crucial for keeping running costs low

2. More refined four-cylinder engine

3. Enhanced safety with six airbags compared to Altroz's two

4. Toyota's reputation for reliability and low maintenance costs

5. Longer wheelbase (2520mm vs 2501mm), potentially offering better interior space

6. Comprehensive feature list including rear AC vents and cruise control

The Glanza offers a well-rounded package that aligns closely with the needs of comfort-seeking family buyers. Its combination of efficiency, comfort, and features, backed by Toyota's reliability, makes it a practical choice.

However, if unique styling, a more advanced transmission, and a top safety rating are priorities, the Altroz is also a worthy contender, especially for those who prioritize standout design and cutting-edge safety.