Toyota Glanza vs Tata Altroz: Reliability vs Safety Hatchback Battle (2024) | Family Car Guide

Key Considerations

Toyota Glanza G:

1. Fuel Efficiency: Boasts an impressive ARAI-rated mileage of 22.35 kmpl, potentially saving you thousands in fuel costs annually.

2. Brand Reputation: Toyota's strong reputation for reliability (with a reported 97% customer satisfaction rate) provides peace of mind for long-term ownership.

3. Safety: Equipped with 6 airbags, offering comprehensive occupant protection.

4. Refined Engine: The 4-cylinder engine delivers smooth performance for both city and highway driving.

5. Feature-Rich: Offers a good mix of convenience features, including automatic climate control.

Tata Altroz XZ:

1. Safety: Achieved a 5-star Global NCAP safety rating, the highest in its class, providing top-notch protection for your family.

2. Spacious Interior: With a class-leading width of 1755mm, it offers generous shoulder room for passengers.

3. Distinctive Design: Its unique "concept car for the road" aesthetic makes it stand out in parking lots and on the road.

4. Ride Comfort: Well-tuned suspension strikes a balance between comfort and handling.

5. Value Proposition: Offers a competitive feature set at its price point.

Let's dive into the numbers:

1. Price:

- Toyota Glanza G: Rs 878,000

- Tata Altroz XZ: Rs 859,900

- Price difference: Rs 18,100 (Altroz is 2.06% cheaper)

2. Engine Performance:

- Glanza G: 88.50bhp, 113Nm

- Altroz XZ: 86.79bhp, 115Nm

- The Glanza G has a slight edge in horsepower (1.97% more), while the Altroz offers marginally more torque (1.77% more).

3. Fuel Efficiency:

- Glanza G: 22.35 kmpl

- Altroz XZ: 19.33 kmpl

- The Glanza G is 15.6% more fuel-efficient, which could result in significant savings over time.

4. Dimensions (in mm):

- Length: Both 3990

- Width: Altroz 1755 vs Glanza 1745

- Height: Altroz 1523 vs Glanza 1500

- Wheelbase: Glanza 2520 vs Altroz 2501

5. Boot Space:

- Altroz XZ: 345 liters

- Glanza G: Not specified (but likely similar to Baleno's 318 liters)

Exterior Design:

The Toyota Glanza G sports a modern yet conservative design, staying true to Toyota's styling philosophy. It's like that dependable friend who always looks put-together without trying too hard.

The Tata Altroz XZ, in contrast, turns heads with its "concept car for the road" look. If cars were outfits, the Glanza would be a well-tailored suit, while the Altroz would be a fashion-forward ensemble.

Interior and Comfort:

The Glanza G’s interiors are impressive, well-designed and with good quality materials - it's like walking into a cozy, well-organized living room.

The Altroz XZ features a layered dashboard effect with textured plastics, a high-mounted touchscreen, and a 15L cooled glove box. .

Both offer comfortable seating, but the Altroz's flat rear floor might be a boon for that occasional three-passenger rear seat scenario - think of it as the difference between a loveseat and a full-sized couch.

Driving Experience:

Behind the wheel, the Glanza G's 4-cylinder engine purrs like a contented cat, offering smooth performance for both city errands and highway road trips. The Altroz XZ's 3-cylinder engine, while adequate, might remind you more of an eager puppy - enthusiastic but occasionally less refined.

Both feature light clutch action, making them as easy to maneuver in stop-and-go traffic as navigating a shopping cart through a busy supermarket.

Practicality:

IThe Altroz's larger boot space (345L vs estimated 318L for Glanza) might accommodate that extra suitcase, while its 90-degree opening doors could make loading and unloading a breeze.

However, the Glanza's superior fuel efficiency could mean fewer stops at the pump, potentially saving you both time and money on longer journeys.

Feature Comparison

1. Infotainment: Both cars offer a 7-inch touchscreen with smartphone connectivity, ensuring you stay connected on the go.

2. Safety: The Glanza G includes 6 airbags, while the Altroz XZ has 2. However, the Altroz's 5-star Global NCAP rating offers additional peace of mind. It's like choosing between a car with more individual life jackets versus one with a sturdier hull.

3. Comfort Features: Both provide automatic climate control, rear AC vents, and keyless entry, enhancing everyday convenience.

4. Connectivity: The Glanza G offers real-time vehicle tracking and connected car features, while the Altroz XZ doesn't offer these features.

Recommendation

For comfort-seeking families in the Rs 8-10 lakh range, the Toyota Glanza G edges ahead as our recommendation, despite its slightly higher price. Its superior fuel efficiency (22.35 kmpl vs 19.33 kmpl) could lead to substantial long-term savings - think of it as an extra family dinner out every month! The smooth 4-cylinder engine, comprehensive safety features, and Toyota's stellar reputation for reliability (97% customer satisfaction) make it a solid choice for family use.

However, if unique styling and a larger boot space are high on your priority list, the Tata Altroz XZ presents a strong alternative, bolstered by its impressive 5-star safety rating. It's like choosing between a reliable family sedan and a stylish.